Dodd's first non-Disney role was as Sandy in a regional production of Grease. She then took understudy roles in the Las Vegas productions of We Will Rock You and Hairspray, before becoming a cast member of the musical Wicked.
''Wicked''
Dodd made her Wicked debut on December 5, 2006, as part of the ensemble of show's first national touring company. She also understudied both Elphaba and Nessarose. Her first performance as Nessarose was at the matinee on March 25, 2007 in Miami, Florida; her first performance as Elphaba was at the matinee on April 7, 2007 in Houston, Texas. Dodd departed the first national touring company on December 2, 2007 in Hartford, Connecticut. After a year on tour, she replaced Jenna Leigh Green as principal Nessarose in the Los Angeles sit-down production. Her first performance took place on December 13, 2007. From late March through early May 2008, she temporarily took over the position of Elphaba understudy, due to the injury of fellow cast member Courtney Corey. Her first performance as Elphaba in Los Angeles took place on April 22, 2008. On May 13, 2008, she replaced Teal Wicks as the standby for Elphaba, due to Wicks' promotion to full-time lead. In addition, she returned to understudying Nessarose, with Briana Yacavone replacing her in the lead role. She departed the Los Angeles company on October 26, 2008. Dodd was succeeded by Vicki Noon as the standby to Elphaba. Dodd then joined the Broadway production, replacing Kerry Ellis in the lead role of Elphaba on November 11, 2008. Upon her move to Broadway, Dodd became the first, and only actress to date, to have performed in the lead roles of both Nessarose and Elphaba. She ended her limited Broadway engagement on January 11, 2009, and was replaced by Nicole Parker. Dodd then originated the role of Elphaba on the second national touring company of the show, which began performances March 7, 2009 and officially opened March 12. Dodd exited the touring company on April 4, 2010, and was once again succeeded by Vicki Noon. She then succeeded Eden Espinosa as Elphaba in the San Francisco sit-down production of the show on June 29, 2010. She remained with the production until it closed on September 5, 2010.