Daugherty became a PBA member in 2001, and started bowling regularly on the PBA Tour in the 2003–04 season. After three seasons of little success as a full time Tour bowler, he returned to bowling mostly in PBA Regional Tour events for the next six seasons.
By way of his Regional Tour titles, Daugherty made the initial "Champions" field for the 2011 PBA Tournament of Champions. He fought his way into the "Elite" field and made the January 22 televised finals as the #2 seed, where he faced #3 seed Mika Koivuniemi in the semifinal match. Daugherty wound up on the wrong end of PBA history that day, rolling seven splitsen route to a record-low 100 score. With Koivuniemi nearly missing perfection and bowling a 299 in the same match, Daugherty also became half of the most lopsided match in PBA history. Despite the embarrassment, Daugherty ran around and high-fived the crowd after making the two pins he needed to reach the 100 mark. He cashed $50,000 for his third-place finish. In the next season’s Tournament of Champions, Daugherty again made the Elite Field and was candid about the previous year’s debacle:
Success in 2012
Daugherty returned to full-time touring status in the 2012–13 PBA season. He finally found success, winning his first national PBA Tour title on November 11, 2012 at the PBA Bowlers Journal Scorpion Championship in Las Vegas.
Additional career highlights
Daugherty finished third at the 2015 PBA Players Championship, his best finish in a major since 2011. He was also a member of the Bass Pro ShopsSilver Lake Atom Splitters team, which won the 2015 PBA League Elias Cup team title. Daugherty made the TV finals for the 2016 PBA Tournament of Champions and the 2016 USBC Masters, but could not complete the quest for a title in either of these major events. He would win his second PBA Tour title on September 10, 2016 at the PBA Wolf Open in Allen Park, Michigan. Daugherty was again a member of the Silver Lake Atom Splitters team, which won the PBA League title in. While he didn't win a title in 2019, Daugherty made a career-high 13 match play rounds and cashed a career-high $74,155 in PBA Tour earnings.
Personal
Daugherty has three daughters and a son. In addition to earning a living on the lanes, he operates two bowling pro shops in the Tampa Bay Area.