Meechan was born in Broxburn, West Lothian, the son of a shale miner who had migrated from Donegal in Ireland. In his youth, he played amateur football for three local football clubs, Broxburn Emmett, Broxburn Shamrock and Broxburn F.C., before joining Hibernian in February 1892. In December 1891, Broxburn Shamrock played the holders of the Scottish Cup, Heart of Midlothian, in a sixth round tie. Despite being the team captain, Meechan refused to play in the match, won 5–4 by Hearts, because of a dispute over the "terms" under which he would play. In June 1893, he moved south of the border to join Sunderland for whom he made 60 appearances, scoring once, helping them to become Football League champions in 1894–95. While at Sunderland, he was the subject of a dispute in the West Lothian Courier, when a contributor challenged his right to register to vote at Broxburn, while living and working in England. In May 1895, Meechan returned to Scotland to join Celtic, helping them take the Scottish championship in 1895–96. In his time at Celtic, he made an appearance for the Scottish Football League against the Irish League on 15 February 1896, followed by his sole international appearance for Scotland, in a 3–3 draw with Ireland on 28 March 1896. His Celtic career ended on a controversial note when he, and two other players, refused to play a match against Hibernian in November 1896. Meechan together with John Divers and Barney Battles refused to play because of the presence at the stadium of a reporter who had heavily criticised Celtic following a Glasgow Cup defeat against Rangers the previous week. Following his "strike", Celtic suspended the three men, with Meechan and Divers being released. In January 1897, Meechan and Divers joined Everton, with Meechan helping them reach the final of the FA Cup in 1897, which was won 3–2 by Aston Villa. In his one and a half seasons with Everton, Meechan made a total of 28 appearances. In August 1898, Meechan moved to the south coast for a club record fee of £200, when he joined a Southampton team that was dominating the Southern League and contained a host of international and ex-First Division players. So good were they that they easily despatched three top flight clubs, including Meechan's former Everton teammates on their way to the 1900 Cup Final against Bury. On the day of the game Meechan, and his Scottish colleagues were angered by the selection of an out of form English forward, Jack Farrell, over the free scoring Roddy McLeod who had played brilliantly in the games leading up to the final. The English players wanted their forward in the team and got their way. The bitterness between the two camps showed on the field and led to a 4–0 defeat. Following the bitter dispute at Southampton, Meechan joined Manchester Cityin September1900, for whom he made six appearances in the 1900–01 season. He made his City debut in a 2–1 win against Sheffield United. He left Manchester at the end of the season to join Barrow in the Lancashire League for a season before re-joining Broxburn F.C. in March 1902. He then spent the 1903–04 season in the Scottish Second Division with Clyde before returning to his home town to play out his career with Broxburn Shamrock.
Life after football
In 1905, Meechan migrated to Nova Scotia in Canada, where he failed to find employment as a football coach and returned to mining. Meechan died in Port Morien in mid-1915, aged 43, with his wife, Annie Thompson, expecting their eighth child. The cause of his death was variously attributed to appendicitis or pneumonia brought about after spending a night in the snow looking for a missing relative, possibly aggravated by his work as a miner.
