"Nunawading Football Club" was first used in 1894, when the Mitcham, Box Hill and Surrey Hills Football Clubs merged to play in the Metropolitan Junior Football Association. The three teams were struggling to field sides at that time and joined together for two seasons, before going their separate ways again in 1896. Surrey Hills however, continued to use the Nunawading title until 1907. The current Nunawading Football Club was established in 1927 as the Tunstall Football Club. Home games were played at the Nunawading Recreation Reserve in Silver Grove. The club played in the Box Hill Reporter District Football Association before moving to the Ringwood District Football League in 1928 and remaining until 1932. From 1933 until 1961 the club played in the Eastern Suburbs Football League. The first premiership was won in 1938 in B Grade. In 1943, the suburb of Tunstall changed its name to Nunawading and the club soon followed. The second premiership was won in 1955, also in B Grade. In 1962 the club affiliated with the newly established Eastern District Football League as a foundation member. By 1974 the club moved to Mahoneys Reserve in Forest Hill, as the Nunawading Recreation centre was being built. Finally, in 1996 the decision was made to move to Koonung Park in Springfield Road, Blackburn North as there were no social facilities at Mahoneys Reserve. During this period the only premiership success were the 1962, 1976 and 1987. After a lean period which included five successive wooden spoons, the club recovered somewhat in 2001, to narrowly miss the finals by percentage. In 2002, the club achieved its first senior premiership in 47 years, defeating Heathmont by 93 points in Division 4 and promotion to Division 3. The club finished seventh in their first two seasons before improving to fifth and missing out on percentage. 2006 saw the Seniors play finals, defeating Waverley Blues in the First Semi but losing to eventual premier South Croydon by twelve points in the Preliminary Final. The Reserves won the premiership by three points. In 2007, the Seniors lost to Upper Ferntree Gully in the First Semi, and in 2008 finished 2nd on the ladder but lost both Finals. The Reserves won the Grand Final defeating Mooroolbark by 61 points. Unfortunately, Nunawading suffered an exodus of players and administrators in the 2010 pre-season, leaving the club with no prospect of being competitive in Division 3 that year. Subsequently, the EFL granted the club's request to be relegated, with Division 4 runner-up Kilsyth taking their place in Division 3. As of the end of the 2018 season, the senior side has a losing streak of 62 matches. Their reserves side had a streak of 55, which was ended in round 12 2018 with a win over the Glen Waverley Hawks in 2018 by six points. The seniors losing streak ended in round one of the 2019 season with a victory over Kilsyth.
