The Burley Cubs became the first professional baseball team to hail from Greeneville, Tennessee, when they joined the Appalachian League in 1921. They opened their inaugural season with a 2–1 road victory over the Johnson City Soldiers on May 12. Greeneville won the first half of the league's split season on the way to compiling a full season record of 58–48. In the postseason championship playoffs, the Burley Cubs lost to Johnson City, five games to one. Greeneville ended the 1922 season last of six teams with a record of 50–70. The 1923 team improved to 51–56. From 1924 to 1925, the club was managed by former Baltimore TerrapinscatcherHarvey Russell. He led the team to a third-place 54–52 finish in 1924, but they missed the playoffs having not won either half of the season. On July 15, 1925, the Bristol State Linersdropped out of the league due to financial difficulties, and the remaining three-team league disbanded the same day. The Burley Cubs lost both games of a doubleheader to the Morristown Roosters, 3–2 and 10–4, on July 15. At the time of the disbandment, Greeneville was in first place with a 28–16 record, making them the de facto pennant winners. Over five years of competition, the team's all-time record was 250–222.
Second stretch (1938–1942)
The Appalachian League reorganized 12 years later in 1937 without a Greeneville team. The Burley Cubs were revived in 1938 as an affiliate of the Chicago Cubs. They won their May 12 Opening Dayroad game versus the Newport Canners, 9–4. They were defeated in the next day's home opener against Newport, 10–3. Greeneville ended the season in third place, qualifying for the playoffs, at 60–45. They won the semifinals, defeating the Elizabethton Betsy Red Sox, two games to none. They then won the Appalachian League championship against the Kingsport Cherokees, 3–1. In 1939, the team became an affiliate of the Cleveland Indians. They qualified for the playoffs again with a fourth-place 65–54 finish, but were eliminated by Elizabethton in the first round, 2–1. The 1940 club, which had re-affiliated with the Chicago Cubs, qualified for the league's expanded playoffs with a fifth-place mark at 55–63. They defeated Newport, 2–1, to advance to the semifinals, where they lost to the Johnson City Cardinals, 2–1. An unaffiliated 1941 team placed placed fifth, missing a contracted version of the playoffs, at 43–75. The Burly Cubs affiliated with the Boston Braves for 1942 and were managed by ex-major leaguer Dale Alexander. On June 15, standing last of six teams, Greeneville surrendered its franchise to the Appalachian League. Their 9–27 record hampered attendance, resulting in financial problems for owner Carl Lyerly. They dropped their final two games to Elizabethton, a June 12 home doubleheader, 5–0 and 9–4. Over their second five-year run, the team accumulated a record of 232–264. Combining all 10 years of competition, their all-time record was 482–486. Greeneville did not return to professional baseball until the Greeneville Astros began competition in the Appalachian League in 2004.
Season-by-season results
Notable players
Nine Burley Cubs also played in at least one game in Major League Baseball during their careers. These players and their season with Greeneville were:
