The modern club was formed in 1922 and joined the Gloucestershire Northern Senior League. They were runners-up in 1935–36 and 1937–38, before winning the league in 1939–39. They subsequently joined the Bristol Charity League, but the league closed down two weeks into the 1939–40 season due to World War II. After the war the club joined Division Two of the Western League. After winning Division Two in 1956–57 they were promoted to Division One. However, the club left the league at the end of the 1958–59 season. Cinderford subsequently rejoined the Gloucestershire Northern Senior League, and were champions in 1960–61 and runners-up in the next two seasons. They joined the Western Division of the Warwickshire Combination in 1963, and were both League Cup winners and Western Division champions in 1964–65, after which they moved up to the Premier Division of the West Midlands League in 1965. In 1968–69 the club reached the LeagueCup final, drawing 1–1 with Kidderminster Harriers, with the league declaring them joint winners. In 1969 the club transferred to the Gloucestershire County League, finishing as runners-up in their first season, and again in 1971–72 and 1973–74. In 1974 they joined Division One of the Midland Combination, which became the Premier Division in 1983. They won the League Cup in 1982–83, beating Bridgnorth Town in the final. However, they returned to the Gloucestershire County League at the end of the 1983–84 season. In 1990 the club joined Division One of the Hellenic League, which they won at the first attempt, earning promotion to the Premier Division. After winning the Premier Division, the Premier Division Cup and the Floodlit Cup in 1994–95, the club were promoted to Division One South of the Southern League. The 1995–96 season saw Cinderford reach the first round of the FA Cupfor the first time. After beating Bromsgrove Rovers 2–1, they lost 3–0 at Gravesend & Northfleet in a second round replay. The club were transferred to the Division One Midlands in 1998, and back to the renamed Division One Western in 1999. In 2000–01 the club won the Gloucestershire Senior Cup, beating Bristol City 1–0 in the final. They were moved back to the Division One Midlands in 2006, before returning to Division One South & West in two years later. In 2015–16 they won the division and were promoted to the Premier Division. The club initially tried to refuse promotion due to concerns about increased costs, but this was rejected by the Football Association. In 2016–17 Cinderford finished bottom of the Premier Division and were relegated to Division One West.
Ground
The club initially played at the Royal Oak ground behind the eponymous public house, before moving to Mousel Barn in 1932. When the club started playing again after World War II they discovered that the ground had been sold off. Two years later they bought three fields on the Causeway, where the Causeway Ground was subsequently built. A stand was erected using a converted tool shed, and two new stands were built in 1949. Floodlights were installed in 1991 and officially inaugurated with a friendly match against Birmingham City. During the 1993–94 season the 18-foot slope from corner to corner was rectified, with the club playing at Worrall Hill while the work was carried out, around five miles from Cinderford. The levelling of the pitch meant banking was created behind one goal and along the side of the pitch opposite the main stand. The ground currently has a capacity of 3,500, of which 250 is seated and 1,000 covered.
