American Idol (season 11)


The eleventh season of American Idol premiered on Fox on January 18, 2012. The show aired on Wednesdays and Thursdays at 8/7c. Ryan Seacrest returned as host, while Randy Jackson, Steven Tyler, and Jennifer Lopez all returned as judges. Interscope Records Chairman Jimmy Iovine, a songwriter and producer, also returned as an in-house mentor to work with the contestants on a weekly basis. This season followed the same format as season 10. Tyler and Lopez announced that they would be leaving the show two months after the finale. Lopez later returned as a judge for the show's thirteenth season.
The season set a record when 132 million votes were gathered for the finale. On May 23, 2012, Phillip Phillips became the winner of the eleventh season of American Idol, beating Jessica Sanchez, the first female recipient of the judges' save.

Regional auditions

Auditions took place in the following cities:
The New Jersey audition was a late addition to the schedule, the audition was held although the attendance was reportedly low. However, the audition episode was not shown, the first time that a scheduled audition that had taken place was not shown. Contestants known to have auditioned in New Jersey were listed as having auditioned elsewhere on the official American Idol website, for example Alex Wong who auditioned in New Jersey has San Diego listed as his audition city on the official website.

Hollywood week and Vegas rounds

The Hollywood rounds of auditions were held at the Pasadena Civic Auditorium starting December 12, 2011. There were 309 contestants at the start of Hollywood Week. The contestants performed solo for the first round, and 185 made the cut. Amongst those sent home included actor/comedian Jim Carrey's daughter, Jane Carrey. The second round involved group performances, and a number of contestants became ill and collapsed in the auditorium. 98 contestants moved on to the third and final round, which were solo performances accompanied by a band or instrument. The contestants were then separated into four rooms, where one room of 28 contestants were all eliminated, while the 70 contestants in the other three rooms all advanced to the Las Vegas round.
After Hollywood, the contestants went to Las Vegas for a challenge round where they performed traditional late 1950s song in groups with Elvis Presley "Viva, Elvis!" show as the backdrop. 28 of the 70 contestants were eliminated. Next came a solo round accompanied by an instrument at the stage for Le Rêve at the Wynn Las Vegas.
After the 42 remaining contestants sang their last solo at the Wynn Las Vegas hotel, they were called one by one to hear the final judgement. Twelve guys and twelve girls were initially announced as the semi-finalists; however, the judges announced plans to add a thirteenth male semi-finalist between Jermaine Jones, Richie Law, Johnny Keyser and David Leathers Jr. The following week, after the male performances, Jermaine Jones was revealed to be the thirteenth performer.

Semi-finalists

The following is a list of semi-finalists who failed to reach the finals:

Semi-finals

The semi-finals round started on February 28. Below are the two semi-final groups with contestants listed in their performance order. The top five males and top five females, along with the three wild card choices by the judges, advanced to the finals. The males started the semifinal round, and the females continued on following night's episode, the contestants perform songs of their choice. This season, long-time vocal coach Debra Byrd was replaced by Jimmy Iovine's own team in the live shows.

Males

Females

Wild Card round

Following those ten singers advancing on Thursday, March 1, six of the remaining 25 semi-finalists were selected by the judges to compete in the Wild Card round. The Wild Card round immediately began, following the announcement of the ten finalists. Following another performance by each Wild Card contender, the judges then selected three contestants to advance to the final group of 13.
OrderContestantSongResult
1Jen Hirsh"Oh! Darling"Eliminated
2Jeremy Rosado"I Know You Won't"Advanced
3Brielle Von Hugel"Someone Like You"Eliminated
4DeAndre Brackensick"Georgia on My Mind"Advanced
5Erika Van Pelt"The Edge of Glory"Advanced
6Reed Grimm"Use Me"Eliminated

Finalists

In this season, maintaining the previous season's format, there were 12 weeks of the finals and 13 finalists, with one finalist eliminated per week based on the American public's votes. Previous season's winner Scotty McCreery recorded the Tim McGraw song cover "Please Remember Me" as the send-off song played when a contestant is eliminated. Jimmy Iovine resumed duties as a weekly mentor to the contestants, frequently assisted by guest mentors. This season, the fashion designer Tommy Hilfiger and Soyon An were employed as image advisers for the Top 10 finalists.

Top 13 – Whitney Houston and Stevie Wonder

On March 7, 2012, the women performed Whitney Houston songs and the men performed Stevie Wonder songs. Ryan Seacrest stated that it would be a competition between the male and female contestants. As a result, the bottom three of each gender, as well as the male and female contestant who received the lowest number of votes amongst their gender, were announced the next night, and the judges chose who went home. However, this will not count as the supposed "Judges' Save" which can only be used once in the competition before the Top 5. Between Jeremy Rosado and Elise Testone, each of whom received the lowest number of votes for their respective gender groups, the judges used the Top 13 Save on Elise Testone and chose to eliminate Jeremy Rosado from the competition.
OrderContestantSongResult
1Joshua Ledet"I Wish"Bottom 3
2Elise Testone"I'm Your Baby Tonight"Saved
3Jermaine Jones"Knocks Me Off My Feet"Bottom 3
4Erika Van Pelt"I Believe in You and Me"Bottom 3
5Colton Dixon"Lately"Safe
6Shannon Magrane"I Have Nothing"Bottom 3
7DeAndre Brackensick"Master Blaster "Safe
8Skylar Laine"Where Do Broken Hearts Go"Safe
9Heejun Han"All in Love Is Fair"Safe
10Hollie Cavanagh"All the Man That I Need"Safe
11Jeremy Rosado"Ribbon in the Sky"Eliminated
12Jessica Sanchez"I Will Always Love You"Safe
13Phillip Phillips"Superstition"Safe

Due to a hidden criminal past, Jermaine Jones was disqualified prior to the Wednesday performance show. Footage of executive producers Nigel Lythgoe and Ken Warwick confronting Jones was shown in what would have been his performance slot, in between Van Pelt's and Laine's performances. A clip of his rehearsal, singing "Somewhere Out There", was shown after his removal from the competition. Voting continued as scheduled with one of the remaining 11 contestants eliminated in addition to Jones, unlike the season 2 disqualification of Corey Clark.
OrderContestantSongYearResult
1Phillip Phillips"Hard to Handle"1990Safe
2Jessica Sanchez"Turn the Beat Around"1995Safe
3Heejun Han"Right Here Waiting"1989Safe
4Elise Testone"Let's Stay Together"1983Bottom 3
5DeAndre Brackensick"Endless Love"1994Safe
6Shannon Magrane"One Sweet Day"1995Eliminated
7Colton Dixon"Broken Heart"1991Safe
8Erika Van Pelt"Heaven"1985Bottom 3
9Skylar Laine"Love Sneakin' Up On You"1994Safe
10Joshua Ledet"When a Man Loves a Woman"1992Safe
11Hollie Cavanagh"The Power of Love"1993Safe

Top 10 – Billy Joel

OrderContestantSongResult
1DeAndre Brackensick"Only the Good Die Young"Bottom 3
2Erika Van Pelt"New York State of Mind"Eliminated
3Joshua Ledet"She's Got a Way"Safe
4Skylar Laine"Shameless"Safe
5Elise Testone"Vienna"Safe
6Phillip Phillips"Movin' Out "Safe
7Hollie Cavanagh"Honesty"Safe
8Heejun Han"My Life"Bottom 3
9Jessica Sanchez"Everybody Has a Dream"Safe
10Colton Dixon"Piano Man"Safe

OrderContestantSongResult
1Colton Dixon"Everything"LifehouseSafe
2Skylar Laine"Gunpowder & Lead"Miranda Lambert
3Colton Dixon, Phillip Phillips & Elise TestoneFleetwood Mac/Stevie NicksN/A
4Heejun Han"A Song for You"Donny HathawayEliminated
5Hollie Cavanagh"Jesus, Take the Wheel"Bottom 3
6DeAndre Brackensick"Sometimes I Cry"Eric BenétSafe
7Jessica Sanchez"Sweet Dreams"BeyoncéSafe
8Michael JacksonN/A
9Phillip Phillips"Still Rainin'"Jonny LangSafe
10Joshua Ledet"Without You"Mariah CareySafe
11Hollie Cavanagh, Skylar Laine & Jessica Sanchez"Like a Prayer" / "Borderline" / "Express Yourself"MadonnaN/A
12Elise Testone"Whole Lotta Love"Led ZeppelinSafe

Top 8 – Songs from the 1980s

OrderContestantSongResult
1DeAndre Brackensick"I Like It"Eliminated
2Elise Testone"I Want to Know What Love Is"Bottom 3
3Colton Dixon & Skylar Laine"Islands in the Stream"N/A
4Phillip Phillips"That's All"Safe
5DeAndre Brackensick & Hollie Cavanagh"I'm So Excited"N/A
6Joshua Ledet"If You Don't Know Me by Now"Safe
7Jessica Sanchez"How Will I Know"Safe
8Phillip Phillips & Elise Testone"Stop Draggin' My Heart Around"N/A
9Hollie Cavanagh"Flashdance... What a Feeling"Bottom 3
10Joshua Ledet & Jessica Sanchez"I Knew You Were Waiting "N/A
11Colton Dixon"Time After Time"Safe
12Skylar Laine"Wind Beneath My Wings"Safe

Top 7 (first week) – Songs from the 2010s

OrderContestantSongResult
1Skylar Laine"Didn't You Know How Much I Loved You"Safe
2Colton Dixon"Love the Way You Lie"Safe
3Phillip Phillips & Elise Testone"Somebody That I Used to Know"N/A
4Jessica Sanchez"Stuttering"Saved
5Joshua Ledet"Runaway Baby"Bottom 3
6Colton Dixon & Skylar Laine"Don't You Wanna Stay"N/A
7Hollie Cavanagh"Fuckin' Perfect"Safe
8Phillip Phillips"Give a Little More"Safe
9Hollie Cavanagh, Joshua Ledet & Jessica Sanchez"Stronger "N/A
10Elise Testone"You and I"Bottom 3

Each contestant performed two songs: a Billboard number-one hit from the 21st century and a song from the classic soul era. Normally two finalists would be eliminated the week after using the judges' save.
OrderContestantSongResult
1Hollie Cavanagh"Rolling in the Deep"Bottom 3
2Colton Dixon"Bad Romance"Eliminated
3Elise Testone"No One"Bottom 3
4Phillip Phillips"U Got It Bad"Safe
5Jessica Sanchez"Fallin'"Safe
6Skylar Laine"Born This Way"Safe
7Joshua Ledet"I Believe"Safe
8Hollie Cavanagh"Son of a Preacher Man"Bottom 3
9Colton Dixon"September"Eliminated
10Elise Testone"Let's Get It On"Bottom 3
11Phillip Phillips"In the Midnight Hour"Safe
12Jessica Sanchez"Try a Little Tenderness"Safe
13Skylar Laine"I Heard It Through the Grapevine"Safe
14Joshua Ledet"A Change Is Gonna Come"Safe

OrderContestantSongResult
1Hollie Cavanagh"River Deep – Mountain High"Bottom 2
2Phillip Phillips"The Letter"Safe
3Skylar Laine"Fortunate Son"Eliminated
4Joshua Ledet & Phillip Phillips"You've Lost That Lovin' Feelin'"N/A
5Jessica Sanchez"Proud Mary"Safe
6Joshua Ledet"Ain't Too Proud to Beg"Safe
7Hollie Cavanagh"Bleeding Love"Bottom 2
8Phillip Phillips"Time of the Season"Safe
9N/A
10Skylar Laine"You Don't Have to Say You Love Me"Eliminated
11Jessica Sanchez"You Are So Beautiful"Safe
12Joshua Ledet"To Love Somebody"Safe

Top 4 – Music of California / Songs They Wish They'd Written

OrderContestantSongResult
1Jessica Sanchez"I Have Nothing"Runner-up
2Phillip Phillips"Stand by Me"Winner
3Jessica Sanchez"The Prayer"Runner-up
4Phillip Phillips"Movin' Out "Winner
5Jessica Sanchez"Change Nothing"Runner-up
6Phillip Phillips"Home"Winner

Elimination chart


Results show performances

Controversies

Disqualification of Jermaine Jones

On March 14, finalist Jermaine Jones was disqualified for concealing arrests and outstanding warrants. Jones, however, denied that he had concealed his previous arrests, as he admitted his arrests when he signed up for Idol. A police official in a New Jersey town where he was the target of two arrest warrants said that "the case wasn't big enough to merit going after him in California", and a New Jersey legislator commented that for the show "to expose, embarrass and interrogate a young man without an attorney in front of 40 million viewers was an outrage". Critics suggested that the show may have staged the disqualification to boost ratings. When asked about speculations that producers had prior knowledge of his criminal past and that the producers were simply out to exploit him on-air, Jones replied that "I haven’t even taken my mind into that and why they did what they did, because then I’ll drive myself crazy".

Jennifer Lopez music video

The music video of Jennifer Lopez's song, "Dance Again", which aired on the program, was criticized as inappropriate for younger viewers. Dan Gainor of the Culture and Media Institute wrote, "Even the supposedly family-friendly TV shows like American Idol are never safe in the hands of Hollywood," and went as far as saying her "skanky new video shows how desperate she is to retain her fame despite her fading relevance. Such sexualized videos aren't appropriate for any children to watch, including Lopez's own twins." Jenna Hally Rubenstein from MTV Buzzworthy also commented about the video's content not being appropriate for a family show, "we thought "Idol" was a family show? This video is less "sit on the couch and chill with dad" and more "call your boyfriend over immediately." Ed Masley from AZ central.com said that the video was on the verge of being too "steamy" for the show.

Gender and ethnic biases

Phillip Phillips became the fifth consecutive white male to win the show, which led to some viewers and critics accusing American Idol of having gender and ethnic biases. The bias towards the so-called "white guy with guitar" has been widely commented on before and after the result was known, with some complaining about the predictability of the likely winner. The string of white guitar-playing male winners includes David Cook, Kris Allen, Lee DeWyze, and Scotty McCreery who won seasons 7, 8, 9, and 10 respectively. Just hours before the finale, Richard Rushfield, author of the book American Idol: The Untold Story, said, "You have this alliance between young girls and grandmas and they see it, not necessarily as a contest to create a pop star competing on the contemporary radio, but as…who’s the nicest guy in a popularity contest," he says, "And that has led to this dynasty of four, and possibly now five, consecutive, affable, very nice, good-looking white boys."

Contestants who appeared on other seasons/shows

Thirteen of the contestants from the eleventh season auditioned for the subsequent season and made into the Top 40. Ten of them made into the voting rounds.
Three of the contestants from the eleventh season auditioned for the subsequent season and made into the Top 30.
The premiere was watched by 21.93 million viewers. While at the time it drew the second largest audience of any entertainment program in the television season, it was down 16 percent from the previous year's premiere, which was watched by 26.23 million viewers. After seven consecutive years as the most watched program on primetime television, the eleventh season of American Idol came in second place to NBC Sunday Night Football in total viewers, as well as in the 18/49 demo.
Haley Smith, who was eliminated during Hollywood week, died in a motorcycle accident on August 31, 2019.